Twelve Nannies Quit in Three Months. Then the New Maid Asked the Boys About Their Mother
Robert Carter Was Preparing for an Investor Meeting When Emma Arrived
By the time Emma stepped into Robert Carter’s mansion, a flowerpot lay broken in the middle of the living room. Books, pencils and building blocks were scattered across the marble floor. On the staircase stood six-year-old Oliver and his five-year-old brother, Noah, waiting to see how long their newest target would last.
Robert had an important meeting with investors that morning. He had tried to stop the boys as they emptied the cupboards, but Oliver had laughed. “You’ll be leaving for work soon anyway, Dad. And we’ll do whatever we want!”
Now Robert sat in an armchair with his face in his hands. Twelve nannies had quit in three months. The last one had made it through four hours. Emma, a twenty-seven-year-old former kindergarten teacher, had been hired as a maid after a long job search. She had barely arrived when Robert made her an offer.
“Meet my sons. If you can last at least a week, I’ll pay you double your salary.”
The Boys Expected Emma to Leave Like Everyone Else
Before their mother died, Oliver and Noah had been cheerful children. Afterward, they began drawing on the walls, hiding things that belonged to the staff and pouring juice on freshly cleaned sofas. One nanny opened her handbag to find live beetles inside. Another slipped on toys the boys had deliberately scattered outside her bedroom.
Robert ran a large construction company. He left early and came home late, relying on a succession of nannies to get the boys through their days. When he saw how unhappy they were, he bought them expensive toys and organized parties. By the morning Emma arrived, there were enough toys in the house for the boys to cover much of the living room floor with them.
Oliver folded his arms and looked down at Emma. “You’ll run away soon, too. We’ve already chased away twelve nannies!”
“And I can make sure you leave today!” Noah added. He kicked a toy car down from where he stood. It rolled across the marble and struck Emma’s foot.
“Stop that immediately!” Robert ordered. Neither boy turned toward him. He was about to apologize to Emma when she untied her apron, laid it carefully over a chair and walked to the foot of the stairs.
Emma Gave Them Ten Minutes to Find Five Things
“So, you two are the ones in charge here?” Emma asked. Oliver seemed pleased to be asked. “Yes! And nobody can tell us what to do!”
“Then I have a proposal for you. If you’re really as brave as you say, you should be able to complete one challenge.”
The brothers looked at each other. “What kind of challenge?” Oliver asked. Emma pointed to the living room, where the boys had left the broken pot and everything they had pulled from the cupboards.
“You have ten minutes to find five things among all this stuff that belonged to your mother.”
Oliver’s smile disappeared. “Why do you want our mom’s things?”
“Because I want to know what she was like.”
Noah looked down. “Dad put away almost all her things,” he said. Robert lifted his head. Until then, the conversation had been about the damage the boys had done and how long Emma might put up with it. Now his younger son was talking about the things he could no longer find in his own house.
Oliver Had Overheard a Phone Call Robert Barely Remembered
Emma asked the boys why they wanted every nanny to leave. Oliver stayed quiet for so long that Robert might have expected him to walk away. Then the boy shouted, “Because Dad said a new woman would take care of us! And we don’t want a new mom!”
Robert went pale. “Oliver, who told you that?”
“You did! When you were talking on the phone! You said you would find a woman to replace Mom!”
Robert remembered the call. He had been speaking to his assistant about finding someone to handle the daily care his wife had once provided. He had used words about taking her place. He hadn’t realized either of the boys was listening, and he’d never had a reason to explain what he meant.
Emma crouched so she could speak to both children. “Listen, nobody will ever be able to replace your mother. And I have no intention of doing that. I came here to work, not to take her place.”
Noah’s eyes filled with tears. “And you won’t throw away our pictures with Mom?”
“Of course not. Why would you think anyone wants to throw them away?”
Noah pointed at Robert. “Dad hid all the pictures. Even the one that used to stand beside my bed.”
Robert Learned What the Missing Photograph Had Meant to Noah
Robert had put the photographs away because seeing his wife’s face could make him cry. Removing them had made it easier for him to get through the day. It had never occurred to him what Noah would think when he looked beside his bed and found the picture gone.
Now Robert could hear how that empty spot and the phone call had fit together for the boys. Their mother’s things had begun to disappear. Then they overheard their father say he needed someone who could take her place. Each time a new nanny arrived, the boys thought they knew what she was there to do.
Emma stood up. “Robert, your sons don’t need new toys or expensive presents. They’re afraid that, along with their mother, they’ll lose everything that reminds them of her.”
Robert crossed the room and knelt in front of his sons. “Forgive me, boys. I thought this would make things easier for you.” Oliver put his arms around his father’s neck. He had a request that was simpler than anything Robert had bought him.
“Dad, can you stay home from work today? We want to show you Mom’s photo album.”
The Investor Meeting Went Ahead Without Him
Robert took out his phone and called his assistant. For the first time in years, he canceled an important business meeting. Then he brought Noah into the hug and promised both boys that he would never hide their mother’s photographs again.
Emma helped them find the family albums. The living room was still a mess, but as soon as the boys had the albums, they wanted somewhere to open them. Oliver and Noah began picking up the toys themselves, clearing a place on the floor where they could sit with their father and turn the pages.
There were still arguments and tantrums in the weeks that followed. The boys still made messes. Robert began spending more time with them, and they had opportunities to talk to him about their mother that had been missing from so many of their days. Emma kept coming to work. The brothers stopped trying to make her leave.
A Month Later, Robert Asked Oliver Why Emma Had Stayed
Robert had watched twelve people walk out of the house. A month after Emma arrived, he asked Oliver what had changed. “Oliver, why don’t you and Noah try to make Emma leave anymore?”
Oliver thought for a moment. “Because she’s the only one who didn’t try to make us forget Mom. And she also taught you how to be our dad again.”
Robert held him a little tighter. He thought about the morning he had been ready to leave for a meeting and Oliver had told him exactly what he expected from his father. A few minutes later, that same boy had asked him to stay and look at photographs. Robert was glad he’d been there long enough to hear him ask.