Federal Judge Sets November 23 Deadline for DOJ to Release Handwritten FBI Notes in Epstein Files Case
The Notes Document 2019 Interviews About Allegations Trump Denies
Senior U.S. District Judge Emmet G. Sullivan has ordered the Justice Department to publish handwritten FBI notes from interviews with a woman who accused Donald Trump, Jeffrey Epstein and others of sexually abusing and physically assaulting her when she was a young teenager. Trump has denied the allegations.
Sullivan issued the order on November 9, giving Attorney General Todd Blanche 14 days to add the notes to the department’s online Epstein Library. The order sets November 23 as the publication deadline, with the possibility of an appeal still open.
The records concern interviews conducted in 2019. Some typed reports based on those interviews have already been released. The order calls for publication of the handwritten notes that FBI personnel used to prepare three of those reports.
The Handwritten Notes Preceded Three Formal FBI Reports
The FBI used the notes to prepare three interview reports known as Form 302s. In the interviews, the woman told investigators that she was between 13 and 15 when the alleged abuse and assaults occurred. Her account named Trump and Epstein alongside other people.
The typed reports and the handwritten notes are two records of the same interviews. The reports reflect how FBI personnel documented the interviews in formal summaries. The underlying notes are the material they drew on to prepare those summaries. The lawsuit concerns public access to that earlier layer of documentation.
Readers who have seen the released reports already have access to some of the FBI’s written account of what the woman told investigators. Publishing the handwritten material would let them examine what was recorded in the notes and how that information appeared in the typed reports. The significance of any differences would depend on what the pages actually contain.
The notes record allegations made during interviews. Their release would establish more about how the FBI documented the woman’s account. Whether the alleged events occurred is a separate question, and Sullivan’s disclosure order did not decide it.
The Justice Department Cited Difficulties With Redacting Handwriting
The Justice Department argued that handwritten records presented difficulties when it came to redaction. The dispute centered on whether those difficulties justified withholding the notes from publication. Sullivan rejected the department’s argument and set a deadline for the records to be added to the Epstein Library.
Lawyers for Katie Phang, the journalist and attorney who brought the case, pointed to the department’s handling of other records. They said handwritten notes from roughly 100 other interviews had already been released with redactions. That gave the court a concrete example of the department having processed and published the same general kind of material.
Redactions remain important because the law requires protection for victims. The question before Sullivan was how the department should meet that obligation while also making the records available. The earlier releases cited by Phang’s lawyers showed how the department had dealt with handwritten notes elsewhere in the collection.
Katie Phang’s Lawsuit Challenges How the Department Applied the Transparency Law
The case, Katie Phang v. Todd Blanche, concerns the Justice Department’s implementation of the Epstein Files Transparency Act. The law was signed on November 19, 2025. It requires the government to release its Epstein records while redacting information to protect victims.
On January 30, 2026, the department announced that it had published millions of pages. Phang argues that the department has still fallen short of its obligations under the law. Her challenge brings the focus to a specific set of records whose typed summaries had been made public at least in part, while the handwritten material behind them remained withheld.
The volume of records already released and the treatment of individual documents are distinct issues in the case. The January announcement described the scale of the department’s publication effort. Sullivan’s November order addressed whether these particular notes should also be available. If the order stands, the department must add them to the online collection by November 23.
A Separate Congressional Report Described Allegations From Beatrice Keul
Weeks before Sullivan’s order, Democrats on the House Judiciary Committee released a report describing allegations from Beatrice Keul, a former Miss Switzerland contestant. The report, released October 26, included Keul’s claim that Trump raped her at New York’s Plaza Hotel in 1993.
Keul also alleged that Trump and Epstein targeted young women aged 16 to 22 at the “Donald J. Trump American Dream Pageant.” She described the pageant as a “hunting ground.” These claims came from Keul’s account in the congressional report. The handwritten notes covered by Sullivan’s order concern the woman interviewed by the FBI in 2019.
The White House rejected Keul’s allegations. A spokesperson said “none of these allegations are true” and characterized the committee report as a political attack on the president. No charges have been brought in connection with the allegations described in the congressional report or the 2019 interviews.
What the November 23 Deadline Means for the Records
The immediate question is whether the Justice Department will publish the notes by the court’s deadline or whether an appeal will affect the timing. The court identified the Epstein Library as the place where the records are to appear, alongside the material the department has already released.
If the notes are published, readers will have another record of what the woman told the FBI and what investigators wrote down during the 2019 interviews. They will also be able to compare the underlying notes with the formal reports that followed. The legal dispute over access to those pages can move forward independently of the unresolved allegations they document.